Deciding whether to hold your child back a year before kindergarten is one of the biggest choices you'll face as a parent. This practice, called "redshirting," has become increasingly common as parents worry about their child's readiness for the academic and social demands of elementary school. You're not alone if you're wondering whether your little one needs more time to grow and develop before taking this important step. In this article, we'll walk through everything you need to know about this decision. We'll explore the signs that might indicate your child could benefit from an extra year, the advantages and potential drawbacks of waiting, and how to evaluate your child's unique needs. Our goal is to help you make the best choice for your family, whether that means moving forward with kindergarten or giving your child another year to flourish in a quality preschool environment.
What Does "Holding Back" Really Mean?
When we talk about holding a child back before kindergarten, we mean keeping them in preschool or Daycare for an additional year instead of enrolling them in kindergarten when they first become age-eligible. This gives your child extra time to develop the skills they'll need for elementary school success. Most children start kindergarten around age 5, but the exact cutoff dates vary by state and school district. Some parents choose to wait until their child is nearly 6, especially if their birthday falls close to the cutoff date. This decision isn't about your child being "behind" – it's about timing and ensuring they're truly ready for the next step. At quality daycare centers, this extra year can be incredibly valuable. Your child continues building foundational skills in a nurturing environment designed for their developmental stage. They work on things like following multi-step directions, managing their emotions, and developing the attention span needed for longer learning activities. This additional time often helps children enter kindergarten feeling confident and prepared rather than overwhelmed.Signs Your Child Might Benefit From Another Year
Recognizing whether your child could benefit from an extra year requires looking at several areas of development. Here are key signs that might indicate waiting could be helpful: • Attention and focus challenges: Your child has difficulty sitting still for story time or completing simple activities without frequent breaks • Social skills still developing: They struggle with sharing, taking turns, or playing cooperatively with other children their age • Emotional regulation needs work: Frequent meltdowns, difficulty handling disappointment, or trouble transitioning between activities • Physical development concerns: Challenges with fine motor skills like holding a pencil, cutting with scissors, or gross motor skills like running and jumping • Communication gaps: Difficulty expressing needs clearly, following complex instructions, or engaging in back-and-forth conversations • Academic readiness questions: Not yet recognizing letters, numbers, or showing interest in pre-reading activities • Independence skills: Needs significant help with basic self-care tasks like using the bathroom, putting on shoes, or managing personal belongings Remember, every child develops at their own pace. These signs don't mean anything is wrong with your child – they simply suggest they might thrive with more time to grow and develop these important skills.The Benefits of Waiting Another Year
Choosing to give your child an extra year before kindergarten can offer several meaningful advantages. The most significant benefit is increased confidence and self-esteem. When children enter kindergarten feeling prepared and capable, they're more likely to enjoy learning and participate actively in classroom activities. Academic readiness often improves dramatically with an additional year. Your child has more time to develop pre-literacy skills like recognizing letters and understanding that print carries meaning. They also strengthen their number sense and problem-solving abilities through play-based learning activities. This solid foundation makes the transition to formal academics https://www.goddardschool.com/schools/nj/parsippany/parsippany much smoother. Social and emotional development also benefits from this extra time. Children learn to navigate friendships, resolve conflicts peacefully, and understand classroom expectations. They develop better self-control and learn to manage their emotions in group settings. These skills are just as important as academic abilities for kindergarten success. Physical development continues progressing too. Fine motor skills improve, making tasks like writing and cutting easier. Gross motor development supports playground activities and physical education participation. At The Goddard School of Parsippany, we see how this extra year allows children to develop the stamina and coordination needed for longer school days and more structured activities.Potential Drawbacks to Consider
While waiting can be beneficial, it's important to consider potential challenges as well. One concern is that your child might become bored or unchallenged if they're significantly more advanced than their preschool peers. This can lead to behavioral issues or disengagement from learning activities. There are also social considerations to think about. Your child will be older than many of their future classmates, which might affect friendships and social dynamics. Some children feel different or out of place being the oldest in their class. Additionally, if your child's close friends move on to kindergarten, they might feel left behind or confused about why they're not advancing too. Financial implications matter for many families. An extra year of preschool or daycare represents a significant cost, especially when you were expecting to transition to free public education. This expense needs to be weighed against the potential benefits for your specific situation. Finally, consider your child's own feelings about the decision. Some children are excited about kindergarten and may feel disappointed about waiting. Others feel relieved to have more time. Having honest, age-appropriate conversations with your child can help you understand their perspective and make a decision that feels right for your whole family.How to Evaluate Your Child's Readiness
Skill Area Ready for Kindergarten Needs More Time Attention Span Can focus on activities for 15-20 minutes Struggles to focus for more than 5-10 minutes Social Skills Plays well with others, shares, takes turns Difficulty sharing, frequent conflicts with peers Independence Uses bathroom independently, manages belongings Needs help with basic self-care tasks Communication Speaks clearly, follows multi-step directions Difficulty expressing needs or understanding instructions Emotional Control Handles disappointment, transitions smoothly Frequent meltdowns, difficulty with changes Pre-Academic Skills Recognizes some letters/numbers, interested in books Shows little interest in letters, numbers, or reading This evaluation should be ongoing rather than a one-time assessment. Children grow and change rapidly during the preschool years, so what's true in the fall might be different by spring. We recommend observing your child in various settings and talking with their current teachers about what they're seeing in the classroom.Making the Final Decision
The decision about kindergarten timing should involve multiple perspectives and careful consideration of your family's unique circumstances. Start by having detailed conversations with your child's current teachers and caregivers. They see your child in a structured learning environment and can provide valuable insights about their readiness compared to other children their age. Consider scheduling a kindergarten readiness assessment through your local school district or with an educational professional. These assessments look at various developmental areas and can help identify specific strengths and areas for growth. However, remember that these are just one piece of the puzzle. Think about your family's specific situation too. Will your child be among the youngest or oldest in their class based on the school's cutoff date? How does your child typically handle new challenges and transitions? What does your gut instinct tell you about their readiness? It's also worth considering the quality of programs available to you. A high-quality preschool program that can provide appropriate challenges and support might make waiting more beneficial than entering a kindergarten program that isn't well-suited to your child's needs. Here in Parsippany, families have access to excellent educational options that can support children at various developmental stages.Working With Your Preschool Team
Your child's current preschool teachers and administrators are invaluable partners in this decision-making process. They observe your child daily in a learning environment and can provide specific examples of their academic, social, and emotional development. Don't hesitate to ask detailed questions about how your child compares to their peers and what areas might benefit from additional development time. Quality early childhood programs maintain detailed observations and assessments of each child's progress. Ask to review these records and discuss any concerns or questions you have. Teachers can also provide suggestions for activities and experiences that might help your child develop specific skills, whether they're staying another year or moving on to kindergarten. At The Goddard School of Parsippany, our experienced educators work closely with families to ensure each child receives the support they need. We understand that this decision weighs heavily on parents, and we're committed to providing honest, helpful guidance based on our observations and expertise in child development. If you decide your child would benefit from another year, work with your preschool team to create goals and plans for continued growth. This ensures the extra year is purposeful and beneficial rather than simply more of the same experiences. Making the decision about kindergarten timing is never easy, but you don't have to navigate it alone. Trust your instincts as a parent while gathering information from the professionals who know your child well. Remember that there's no universally "right" choice – only what's best for your individual child and family. Whether your child is ready for kindergarten now or would benefit from another year of growth and development, the most important thing is ensuring they have access to high-quality educational experiences that support their unique needs. The Goddard School of Parsippany is here to support your family through this important transition, providing the nurturing environment and expert guidance your child needs to thrive.Ready to Discuss Your Child's Educational Journey?
The Goddard School of Parsippany311 Smith Rd, Parsippany, NJ 07054
(973) 386-5550
https://www.goddardschool.com/schools/nj/parsippany/parsippany
https://maps.app.goo.gl/SbSyVPhJqNXqFREMA